Thursday, February 25, 2010

To rant or not to rant

 
the omnipresent plume of the pulpmill

 I hate it when one has to wrestle with great moral dilemmas. Twice I had started to write a great blog article - bemoaning the fact that our local editor is apparently backing the "gassification" plant proposed for Kamloops. For those not in this circle - the plant is for waste disposal of creosote soaked railway ties. The argument against is that the burning of the creosote will be nasty for us citizens and result in three eyed trout that will be really hard to catch. The argument for is that science will save the day and that "What's good for General Motors is good for the USA" - or in this case what's good for the backers of the project is ultimately good for Kamloops.

The dilemma is that one can not be against the "gassification" plant without also being against the pulp mill's continued attack against the air quality of the valley. That's where the dilemma comes from. Back in the day I was quite happy to write software for major forest companies that fed the pulp mill and in effect I participated in saying that the cost to the environment was worth the sheckles that fed my family for at least three months out of every year.

The real debate going on right now should be about the direction that Kamloops wishes to go. One can never trust the science behind these plants as being definitive; history is too full of instances where things, once thought safe, turned out to be not so good for you  - blood letting, DDT, thalidomide and Reality TV, to name a few. So if it's not a matter of science it has to come down to a matter of dollars and sense (yes sense not cents): Are the extra dollars in the economy worth the sense of unease that we are running an industrial waste operation within the boundaries of the city.

Myself, I think it would be a great project if they could reroute the emissions from the pulp mill through the burner and kill two birds with one stone and hopefully not provide us with too many three eyed fish in the process.

1 comment:

  1. A friend once told me that the best two things that ever happened to Kamloops were the pulp mill and the Indian Reserve. From comments like that you might figure that my "friend" must be employed by Weyerhaueser or be first nations. But no.
    Imagine no Weyerhaueser or Indian reserve and what would you get? Well 40 years ago some developer would have built housing developments strung along both sides of the Thompson River and Kamloops with a much higher population. Hey a population of 125,000 would be neat. Remember bigger is better just ask Kelowna.

    At least in industry based Kamloops you can still hear horses grazing.

    Doug

    ReplyDelete

Please feel free to leave a comment. Ever since old Rebel rolled on me and I've been strapped to this old hospital bed I've enjoyed whatever posts come my way.